Hold that Thought, - [top 20 books to read .txt] 📗
- Author: -
- Performer: -
Book online «Hold that Thought, - [top 20 books to read .txt] 📗». Author -
I offered a health Survey to a client of mine; we’ll call her Wendy. She came to me because she wanted to lose weight and feared her obesity was going to lead to the heart disease experienced by her parents. The Survey included the statement, “skinny people are shallow,” which Wendy identified with the most. I suggested we focus the rest of our session inquiring about that one belief.
Chana: Is it true that skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: Yes. It feels that way.
Chana: Can you absolutely know it’s true?
Wendy: Hmm. Not for sure. No.
Chana: And how do you react when you believe that skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: I feel bitter and resentful when I see thin people. Even if I don’t know them, and I just see them walking down the street.
Chana: What else?
Wendy: I feel like sinking into my chair. I don’t really want to do anything. It feels heavy. Actually… it makes me feel fatter.
Chana: What are you unable to do when you believe that skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: I can’t think straight. I can’t make good decisions. I for sure can’t eat healthy stuff.
Chana: How do you benefit from believing the thought?
Wendy: The last thing I ever want to be is shallow. Like those ditsy girls in high school who were obsessed with their hair and make-up.
The upcoming question - and many throughout this book - follow the style of Barry Neil Kaufman’s Option Process, in which we question assumptions, seek to clarify the meaning of language, and explore the necessity of our emotions. The aim is to find answers within ourselves. Some Option questions are:
What do you mean when you say….?
Do you need to feel angry in order to make sure you don’t engage in that behavior?
Do you believe that?
How come?
Why did you do that?
How do you feel about that?
Here, I wish to lay out Wendy’s logic in a simple sentence so she can assess whether it serves her.
Chana: Do you have to believe this thought that makes you feel heavy and fat in order to be a deep person?
Wendy: Oh. I never thought of it that way. I guess not. I could just keep reading and thinking and feeling…
Chana: Can you reach your weight and health goals believing that skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: Well, I want to eat healthier, but I also don’t want to be shallow. Being a deep feeling and thinking person is really important to me.
Chana: So you’ve put yourself in a Double Bind. That’s a situation in which you want two things that you’ve made mutually exclusive. You want to be lean and healthy, and you want to be a deep person, but your belief only allows for one of those.
Wendy: And being shallow seems so horrific to me that I chose to be fat.
Chana: Exactly.
Wendy: So how can I change that?
Chana: You can explore other ways of thinking, particularly those that oppose the thought you’re currently believing.
Wendy: I can do that.
Chana: What’s the opposite of skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: Skinny people aren’t shallow?
Chana: Yes. Can you give me three reasons why that’s true?
Wendy: No. Not really.
Chana: Do you know anyone who is skinny and deep?
Wendy: Yes. Yes, I do. There’s Gene and Pamela and … Wow.
Chana: Why did you say, “Wow?”
Wendy: I just realized it’s a lot of people. As soon as I thought about it, I realized how many skinny, deep people I know.
Chana: Each one of those people is a reason why it’s true that skinny people aren’t shallow.
Wendy: That’s a lot of reasons.
Chana: Yes. Can you give me another turnaround for skinny people are shallow?
Wendy: Fat people are shallow.
Chana: Why is that true?
Wendy: Well, I can speak for myself. I end up spending so much time worrying how I look in my clothes when it gets really tight, and I probably shop for clothing more than my skinny friends who stay in the same dress size all the time.
Chana: And one more reason?
Wendy: There are plenty of fat folks reading People magazine and grooming themselves all the time.
Chana: Good to realize. Let’s do one more turnaround. Perhaps make yourself the subject this time. I’m…
Wendy: I’m shallow. Ooh. That hurts. And I can see how that’s true. I’m constantly looking at how others look or wondering what they think of me. I spend more time thinking about food, and I have less energy to do things because my body weighs me down.
Chana: Any other reasons?
Wendy: This is embarrassing. I assume skinny people have no depth just because of how much they weigh - can it get any more shallow than that?
Chana: You’ve put two human qualities, weight and depth, and correlated them. The bigger question here is whether they necessarily have anything to do with one another. Does physical size have anything to do with depth of thinking or feeling?
Wendy: You mean, does being skinny or fat have anything to do with whether you’re deep or shallow?
Chana: Exactly.
Wendy: Not when I stop to think about it. You can be skinny and either deep or shallow. You could also be fat and either deep or shallow. It depends more on your personality than on your frame.
Chana: So which of these qualities do you want for yourself ?
Wendy: I’d like to be thin and deep. That way I can be healthy, have energy, and be able to contribute more in the world.
Chana: Sounds like an inspiring goal.
Through filling out a health Survey, Wendy discovered some challenging beliefs she had lurking under the surface. Wendy had trapped herself in a bind by believing that she’d be missing out on one of her core values, depth, if she worked on one of her life goals, losing weight. By engaging in Inquiry, she was able to see how much suffering she was causing herself with this belief, but also how untrue it was when she faced it head-on.
Use The Survey when you want to quickly get to the core of what you are facing. You’ll easily gather beliefs for Inquiry. Surveys are versatile, can be as long as you want, and can focus on a topic relevant to you or your specific client population. They’re great for working with groups since they illustrate that many of us are struggling with the same beliefs.
Download sample Surveys in the Free Bonus section of my website:
Hold.ChanaMason.com/bonus.
A collection of thoughts or beliefs that cause a person distress.
People who have no hold over their process of thinking are likely to be ruined by liberty of thought. If thought is immature, liberty of thought becomes a method of converting men into animals.
- Muhammad Iqbal
Cindy came to me because she was feeling unhappy and unfulfilled with her life.
Chana: What’s upsetting you?
Cindy: I’m really frustrated with homemaking.
Chana: What about homemaking frustrates you?
Cindy: Well, I want my house to be well kept, but I resent all the work involved.
Chana: What about the work do you resent?
Cindy: I don’t know… Just everything! Everything about keeping my house together annoys me these days.
Because of Cindy’s lack of specificity, I decide it would be best to give her cues, the first words of a belief for her to complete. Cues can help clarify what we really believe. To get everything out on paper quickly, I suggest we build a Thought Bank on the topic of homemaking. I ask Cindy to complete the following sentences:
Cleaning is
Cleaning should be
In regards to housekeeping, I should
Cooking is
Cooking should be
In regards to cooking, I should
I shouldn’t have to
Being a homemaker means
As a homemaker, I should
Cindy was able to focus on completing the sentences and was no longer distracted by the mess in her head about the mess in her house. Here are some of her beliefs:
Cleaning is a chore.
Cleaning should be easy.
I shouldn’t have to pick up after everyone.
Cooking should be fun.
Cooking is overwhelming.
Being a homemaker means putting everyone else first.
As a homemaker, I should always have a smile on my face.
In about fifteen minutes, Cindy and I have built a Thought Bank we can use for numerous sessions.
Chana: (after rereading the list to Cindy) Now do you understand why you’re so resentful?
Cindy: Oh yeah! It’s kind of hard not to be frustrated when this is what I have inside.
Chana: Exactly. Now let’s take another look at your list. Which thought feels the truest and at the same time the most upsetting?
Cindy: Being a homemaker means putting everyone else first.
Chana: Being a homemaker means putting everyone else first. Is it true?
Cindy: Yes.
Chana: Can you absolutely know that it’s true?
Cindy: It sure feels like it, yes.
Chana: And how do you react when you believe that being a homemaker means putting everyone else first?
Cindy: I feel rebellious. I want to fight everyone and everything.
Chana: Anything else?
Cindy: I get tired. And really lazy.
Chana: What are you afraid would happen if you didn’t believe the thought?
Cindy: That I wouldn’t get anything done. That I’d just sit and watch garbage on TV all day.
Chana: Does believing the thought motivate you to get stuff done?
Cindy: Oh….
Chana: Why did you just say that?
Cindy: I just realized it’s exactly the opposite of what I was hoping. Believing I have to put everyone else first feels like so much pressure that I hide behind my favorite magazine and put off doing the laundry.
Chana:
Comments (0)